Thursday, December 9, 2010

Tourism - hero or villian?


The final question is finally here. Is tourism the culprit for the commodification of the cultures and traditions of Argentina?

Both yes and no are correct answers to the question, to certain extents. 

I agree that tourism, to some extent, played a part in commodifying the cultures and traditions of Argentina. When a country look to develop their tourism sector, they do everything possible in order to attract the different forms of market out there in the world, to an extreme where tourism sites no longer wait for people to come, but rather go all out to grab visitors arrivals. Just like many designers out there in the world, tourism sectors change its original looks just to accommodate the needs of consumers. Unfortunately, this happens to Argentina.  Places like Mar del Plata and the La Rioja have been marketed to the outside world that they have forgotten the purpose that each site has been granted due to its naturally appearance and features.  Places that have never allowed entry to visitors before now do as visitors arrival naturally means gain of income as these people generally will spend.

However, there is a no to the question. And in fact, on the contrary, tourism can help to preserve the authenticity of the culture and traditions of Argentina. With popularity of cultural tourism rising rapidly, government of Argentina will do its very best to preserve these culture and heritage in order to “sell” to the consumers. 

As the saying goes, “to lose is to gain and to gain is to lose”, the right way to view the problem is rather find the right balance in determining the worth of sacrifices compared to the gain. If managed correctly, cultural tourism can flourish in Argentina without any commercialisation, dilution or artificial creation of the cultures and heritage.

Changes brought by Tourism


Changes have definitely took place with the rise of tourism is Argentina. And we shall take a look at these changes specifically into economically and socio culturally. 

Economically wise, Argentina definitely benefitted from the rise of tourism. With attractions like the Mar del Plata, Iguana falls and La Rioja, Argentina enjoyed revenue generated from the tourists’ arrivals at these landmarks. 

Development of tourism is a very large scale project, which requires a lot of manpower, be it the manufacturers, architect or the service staff. This helped to reduce the unemployment in Argentina.

The negative impact of tourism economically speaking will be that huge amount of money now has to be pumped into maintenance of the tourism sites regularly.
In terms of socio cultural impacts, there are also both negative and positive.

Positively speaking, tourism offers the world a chance to improve their understanding of one another. Mutual sympathy can thus be forged, reducing any form of prejudice formed before. The interaction between the Argentines and foreigners will also develop a form of cultural exchange. 

Negatively speaking, there is a serious chance of cultural dilution of the Argentines. When foreigners interact with the Argentines citizens, the locals have as much chance of learning the opposition’s culture as the foreigners. The newly learned culture will slowly be instilled into the locals’ heads and dilute the original culture that they have.

Disney of Argentina


If disneyization refers to sectors of the world adopting the principles of Disney Theme Parks with relations to the four dimensions pointed out by Alan Bryman, then I’d be lying if I were to say that Argentina is not disneyized. In fact, in my opinion, at least one sector of every country has gone through disneyization, and perhaps even they themselves do not realise it. 

And in Argentina, I’d like to focus on a particular attraction of the country – Mar del Plata, the biggest beach in Argentina. In truth, the theory works the same way as our Sentosa.
In terms of Disney Theme Park, the core product of the attraction obviously has to be the theme parks. In comparison, the core product of the Mar del Plata beach has to be the beautiful sceneries of the beach, the sea or even the sand. Pretty much everything else that has been established around these core products were forms of disneyization. More to follow below.



 Theming

In the case of Disney Theme Parks, Alan Bryman said “theming accomplished at least two things in this connection. First, it established coherence to the various rides and attractions in Disneyland and the environments in which they were located. Secondly, in the design of rides and attractions, the accent was placed on their theming rather than on the thrill factor, which was the emphasis in traditional amusement parks.” in his book.
The same can be seen in the Mar del Plata beach. When people now go to the beach for a time of relaxation and rejuvenation, they find themselves faced with so many other choices now. The casino, the nightlife or even the industrial port full of sea lions now add much higher excitement to a place decades ago only consists of a beach with mesmerizing beauty. I’d say that the Mar del Plata beach has been “themed”, evolving into a city attraction rather than just a beach attraction. All these have been done in order to attract higher tourist arrivals, which ultimately concerns with the overall revenue generated from the site. The question now is, do people go to the Mar del Plata beach primarily for the beach or for the other added attractions?



2)    Hybrid consumption 

Alan Bryman refers this as a general trend whereby the forms of consumption associated with different institutional spheres become interlocked with each other and increasingly difficult to distinguish. It basically means consumer now has an extra choice of consumption on top of the core product. In the case of Mar del Plata, as visitors enter the area, they are greeted with various shops that sells beach wear, beach activities related equipments, or even food and beverages. The main selling point of the attraction has now been smudged with visitors facing more and more kinds of consumption they get to enjoy.

3)    Merchandising

Alan Bryman refers to this as the promotion and sale of goods in the form of or bearing copyright images and/or logos, including such products made under licence. The two photos below show how souvenirs are being sold with the purpose of promoting the site. 




4)    Performative Labour

Performative labour means the growing tendency for frontline service work to be viewed as a performance, especially one in which the deliberate display of a certain mood is seen as part of the labour involved in service work. In both the Disney Theme Parks and the Mar del Plata beach, the service employees are being told to always put on a smile during their Standard Operating Procedure training. In the port of the Mar del Plata beach, entertainers have to perform with the sea lions for the audience. These entertainers have to attain a desired level of happiness in the audience through the way they talk and perform to the audience. The ultimate concern is if all these emotions portrayed by these service staff are genuine or just staged for the sake of achieving various purposes.

Things Argentina are famous for

Evita
Maria Eva Duarte de Peron, better known as Evita, was the second wife of then President Juan Peron and served as the First Lady of Argentina from 1946 until her death in 1952. Before the emergence of Evita, Eva Peron was famous for her acts in pro-Peronist trade unions, the founding of Eva Peron Foundation, championing of the women’s suffrage and also the founder of the first female political party, the Female Peronist Party.





Bueno Aires’ Obelisk

El Obelisco is the most famous icon of Buenos Aires and a favorite picture postcard of the city. It was built in 1936 to celebrate the 400th anniversary of the first founding of the city by Pedro de Mendoza. The obelisk of Buenos Aires is a popular place for political demonstrations or victory celebrations of football teams fans.


Music and Dance

Agrentina is famous for inventing the tango, a romantic dance and music style. Tourists can get a taste of the tango by going to La Ventana Tango Show in Buenos Aires, a dinner theater in a historic building featuring live orchestras, dancers and singers, plus a dinner menu featuring traditional Argentine food.

Food

Argentina is probably the most famous for its beef dishes. Many tourists made it a necessity to have a taste of Argentina’s steaks when they arrive at the country. Mate drinking is also a well known culture of the country.

Talampaya canyon – La Rioja

The world renowned Talampaya national park was given the prestigious title of UNESCO world heritage site in 2000. It consists of a beautiful but semiarid landscape formed by the action of wind and rain in a desert climate. Besides the red walls of this impressive gorge full of fanciful forms, there are in the park important palaeontological sites.



Leisure activities in Argentina


Football in Argentina is a very popular sport. According to research done by FIFA, it tops the world chart in terms of numbers of players with 2,648,811 in total, 331,811 of which are registered and 2,327,000 unregistered.  The popularity of the sport can be seen from the achievement the national team have achieved, having won the 1978 and 1986 World Cup while also notched the runner up awards in 1930 and 1990. They have also won the top continental tournament, the Copa America, on 14 occasions. This shows the amount of emphasis and efforts placed in cultivating the talent of Argentine footballers.

 The Argentines view tango with love and national pride, as they were the ones that were associated with the origins of the dance. Tango dancing has become a well known leisure in Argentina, particularly during the weekends where people meet up in clubhouses for a good tango-time with one another. 

 Other leisure activities include hanging out in beaches, shopping and also mate drinking among the Argentina men.  


Education system in Argentina


In Argentina, it is compulsory for all children aged between 6 and 14 to attend schools under the enforcement of the law. All levels of education up till high school are free to the public. Still, high school education is generally affordable and available, although attendance does fall by nearly 50% for those older than 14. Like any other countries, there are state and private schools made available, while the general consensus is that schools in city areas are better equipped than those in the country. Many of the subjects provided are the ones globally recognised, such as Science, Mathematics, Languages, Art, History, Sports and Geography. 

The age groups of the education system are as follow: 

Pre-Primary Level (not compulsory): 3 to 5 years old
Primary Level, also known as the Educacion General Basica: consists of 7 grades. Pupils at this level must complete all 7 grades.

EGB I: 1st, 2nd and 3rd grade
EGB II: 4th, 5th and 6th grade
EGB III: 7th grade onwards, until the age of 14.

Secondary Level, also known as the Polimodal: usually aged 12 to 15 years old.  

Higher level of education is divided into 3 levels – the Tertiary Education level, University level and Post-graduate level.